Funding opportunities

Funding Type: 
Transplantation Immunology
Grant Number: 
Principle Investigator: 
Funds requested: 
$1 415 836
Funding Recommendations: 
Grant approved: 
Public Abstract: 

Stem cell therapies have the potential to transform medicine by allowing the regeneration of tissues or organs damaged by disease or trauma. In order for stem cell therapies to proceed, it will be essential that the regulation of immune responses to the stem cell derived tissues be achieved. While the function of the immune system in protection from infections is essential throughout life, some immune reactions are undesirable. Illnesses due to autoimmunity, in which the immune system attacks one’s own body, instead of only germs that cause infection, are common. Examples of autoimmune diseases that are amenable to stem cell based therapies include Type I diabetes caused by abnormal immune responses directed against the insulin producing cells and multiple sclerosis (MS) caused by immune responses that attack the nervous system. Another type of undesirable immune response is the attack on transplanted tissues, leading to rejection. Control of immune reactions is the major impediment to successful organ transplantation, and is highly likely to be an obstacle to therapeutic uses of stem cells.

T lymphocytes are white blood cells that choreograph the multiple responses that the body uses to control infection. T lymphocytes are produced in the thymus, a specialized organ located in the chest in front of the heart. A function of the thymus is to “edit” the immune response by selecting desirable T cells that are allowed to grow up, and removing young T cells that would cause autoimmunity if they were released into the body. Abnormal selection in the thymus, due to genetic variation, disease or errors in editing leads to autoimmune disease. On the other hand, replacement of the immune system by bone marrow transplantation can be used to engineer the immune system so that the body will accept organ transplants if they came from the same donor as the bone marrow.

We are evaluating a stem cell based strategy to control the editing of the immune response to both treat autoimmunity and permit stem cell-derived tissues to be transplanted. Members of the international collaborative team have developed techniques for directing embryonic stem cells (ESC) into specialized thymic epithelial cells (TEC), which can be transplanted into recipient mice to support the development of new T cells. We have also developed mouse models for MS and for stem cell rejection which can be controlled by modification or suppression of the immune system. We will evaluate the ability of TEC made from ESC to 1) edit the immune system to prevent or treat MS, or 2) allow ESC to be transplanted without rejection. The studies will test TEC to support the production of new T cells that can respond normally to germs, but will not attack either nervous system cells or transplanted ESC. Success of the studies will advance our understanding of how to regulate the immune system for the goal of using stem cells therapies to treat disease and regenerate tissues.

Statement of Benefit to California: 

The research is aimed at understanding the how ESC can be used to re-engineer immune responses so that autoimmune diseases can be controlled and other stem cell derived tissues can be transplanted. The studies are based on our team’s demonstration that functional TEC can be generated from ESC. Since TEC are very important for selection in the thymus of which T cells will be allowed to mature and become part of the immune system. The studies will explore two models for the use of such ESC-derived TEC – 1) an autoimmune disease of mice that mimics many aspects of human multiple sclerosis; and 2) transplantation of ESC from between genetically non-identical donors and recipients.

Autoimmunity is a major cause of disease in California. A recent study of the Kaiser Northern California patient population estimated an overall incidence for 11 autoimmune diseases of 160 new cases per 100,000 person years (PY)(Klein NP et al, Vaccine [2009] 28:1062-68). With an estimated California population of 37 million, this translates to nearly 60,000 new cases of autoimmune disease yearly. Furthermore, many of these diseases are disproportionately found in younger individuals, thereby amplifying the potential effects of disability on the population. The autoimmune disease that is being approached in this grant, multiple sclerosis (MS), has the fourth highest incidence in the Kaiser study at 14.2 cases/100,000 PY overall, and 22.9 cases/100,000 PY for women 25-62 years of age. The proposed studies include a novel use of ESC to control autoimmune responses in mouse models of MS as well as a novel approach to immune suppression, which could have a significant impact on MS and autoimmune diseases in general.

The second proposed application of ESC-derived TEC is the control of rejection of transplanted ESC. Since one of the limitations of all ESC-based therapies is likely to be immune responses leading to rejection of the transplanted tissues, a strategy to make recipients tolerant to the ESC has the potential to benefit all Californians who might benefit from stem cell based therapies. Examples would include patients who could benefit from regenerated nervous system, heart, liver or kidney tissue, as well islet cells for treating diabetes. The proposed studies include the innovative use of ESC-derived TEC to re-engineer the immune system to allow it to accept (become tolerant of) cells derived from the same ESC, an approach that could significantly advance the development of treatments for all Californians likely to benefit from stem cell therapies.

Review Summary: 

This proposal aims to evaluate the feasibility of using embryonic stem cell (ESC)-derived thymic epithelial cells (TECs) to generate a new thymic microenvironment in order to induce tolerance to both auto- and alloantigens including allogeneic ESCs. Aim 1 will assess the ability of murine ESC-derived TECs to reconstitute the immune system and generate a functional T cell compartment in the thymic microenvironment. Aim 2 will determine the impact of ESC-derived TECs on tolerance induction in experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE), a preclinical model of multiple sclerosis. Aim 3 will test whether immune responses directed against transplanted ESC- or iPSC-derived cells can be modulated by co-transplantation of TECs derived from either ESC or iPSC that are syngeneic with the donor tissue.

The reviewers collectively agreed that the proposal is highly innovative and possesses the potential for significant impact. If successful, it would be a major advance. Reviewers noted that the method the applicants propose to employ to generate the TECs from ESC is a novel technique and they lauded the creative combination of this approach with the EAE and co-transplantation models. One reviewer commented that this project’s success could lead to significant advances in the use of ESC-derived TECs and could provide data for a future application in the clinical setting.

Reviewers also praised the research plan and experimental design. They found the proposal to be well structured and designed, and agreed that the aims are logical and well articulated. They commented that the methodology used to generate ESC-derived TEC is well thought out. Reviewers also agreed that potential pitfalls are identified and discussed and that alternate strategies are evaluated. While remaining enthusiastic about the proposal, the reviewers voiced some minor reservations and recommendations for the applicant. For example, while the preliminary data in general support the strategies proposed, one reviewer would have liked to see a more robust analysis of the ESC-derived TEC, including an analysis of TEC subsets to determine whether all subsets are present (a vital issue for tolerance induction) and a demonstration that mature TEC are generated with high frequency and that functionally relevant genes are expressed. This reviewer also recommended that the applicant address issues such as the optimum differentiation state of TEC for use in grafting protocols such as those outlined, the differentiation state of the TEC generated by the ES cell differentiation protocol, and whether this protocol transfers well to ES cells of other genetic backgrounds. Reviewers also recommended that the applicant evaluate the potential tumor risk of ESC-derived TECs.

The reviewers uniformly praised the PI, co-investigator, and the research team, and judged them to be qualified to conduct the project. The complementary expertise of these groups should facilitate the accomplishment of the project’s aims. The PI’s allocation of 15% effort shows commitment to the project’s execution and the reviewers valued the contributions made by the Collaborative Funding Partner component of the collaboration as well as the co-investigator’s contribution.

In summary, the proposal’s outstanding research team and highly innovative, creative and well-designed research plan bolstered the reviewers’ enthusiasm for this project. Concerns regarding aspects of the preliminary data were voiced, but could be overcome by a robust characterization to assure that functional TEC are generated.

  • Bruce Blazar